Morning Matt,
I was the tech that sent you the email stating that I put my email address in and got the email verifying my settings were correct. I also sent you an image showing you this.
Also, I mentioned to you that your using all AOL emails, the only Gmail email in the settings is the Username. You need to use Gmial for the sender as well, and more than likely the receiver. I suggested that you test it with Gmail and not AOL email addresses, was that done?
Thank You.